繁体版
梁静茹《静茹&情歌》
发行：相信音乐
如果几行抒情的文案，还有几句不断重复的“我爱你”就是爱情，或许这次的制作团队低估了爱情。
这是所有梁静茹的专辑中，我最失望的一张。
摆明了《静茹&情歌》，以为会听见那些对于爱情更深刻的见解，更能唱进心底的情歌。结果是，完全没有。连一首情歌都不能，即便歌名是《情歌》也徒然无功。
《情歌》中段听起来很像《可惜不是你》，但后者的旋律徘徊不去。《别再为他流泪》如果是《分手快乐》的延续，那也只是一次更简单化的假设。劝解说的不费力气，因为也只不过是说了N次的老套安慰，模式Copy 得彻底，当然不费力气。
坦白说，连小寒老师作词的《用力抱着》也略嫌一般。少了以往的精辟，也体会不了“用力抱着”的复杂情绪，有些句子也觉得押韵的痕迹大于故事的流畅。但更有可能的是，曲本身已经不吸引人，就算有感动也会打折。
最失望的莫过于和曹格合作的“PK”。梁静茹+曹格这样的梦幻卡司，却只能交出如此中规中矩的作品，浪费了彼此的时间，也浪费了听众的时间。“PK”不是不好听，只是交给任何歌唱水平OK的男女歌手都能胜任，又何必劳驾两位。
专辑到了后段，开始显得混乱。《风笛手》听来格格不入，而即使我喜欢《不敢当》，但把摇滚摆在两首情歌中间实在失策。如果是紧接《没有如果》或许情绪连贯性会比较顺畅。《儿歌》这种很方文良类歌曲，一向来都很不合我的口味，自然不会打下好分数。
幸亏《属于》算是扳回一城，虽然明显跟着《崇拜》的模式走，但至少还能激起心中一点点的涟漪。刘沁的创作《找个人》虽然歌词普通得可以，但胜在编曲出色，慵懒的氛围听来舒服。虽然《没有如果》熟口熟脸但至少对梁静茹而言算是新鲜的尝试。参考若能比原曲好听，也是功力。庆幸《没有如果》做到了。
来到第十张大碟的梁静茹，真的遇到碰不着好歌的大瓶颈。这几年，相信音乐好像除了把五月天的专辑做好以外，似乎难以让我们真的相信音乐。
讽刺？那是现实。
我打5分
我请你听《没有如果》、《属于》、《找个人》
BY 老黄瓜
《没有如果》
文章標籤
全站熱搜
商業化但卻能雅俗共賞
梁靜茹真是一個特例
“相信音乐好像除了把五月天的专辑做好以外，似乎难以让我们真的相信音乐。”
他们把钱炸在五月天的烟火秀上面了呀。
真的很希望阿信能够再为fish创作，觉得他的创作每次都很适合梁静茹。
超爱“燕尾蝶”。=D
Haha I dont think it is as bad as you made it sound like bah... Song-
wise, this album is surely not as attractive & addictive as her
previous (especially when Chong Bai was really a great success - in
fact every song is worth it) but i thought Qing Ge and Ai Qing Zhi Suo
Yi Wei Ai Qing are great attempts especially the former.. it brought
back many nice and not so nice memories for me... I think Qing Ge is
the best song in this album :)
That being said, i feel that Yong Li Bao Zhe really sounds like a
weaker version of Wo Men Jiu Dao Zhe (which itself is already weak
enough). And the starting of Tian Deng really sounds like another song
(which i forgot which one). I also agree with you that there's a
serious problem with the sequencing of songs...
It's not bad an album but when compared to Fish's previous ones, it is
not as attractive... But seriously from 2008 December till now, only
her album together with Joanna and Cheer's are worth listening... I
rate the album around 7.5/10
I agree with Moses analysis and his comments. Mr Old Cucumber
too "nasty" liao. Gave only 5 marks. Not say I too kind, this album I
am going to give v high marks cos at least there is breakthrough.
Sometimes singing too much ballads may be bored, Fish may have the
choice or decision to sing other varieties of music, why can't?
Seriously speaking, I only disappointed with her hit song mei you ru
guo.
Although her strength is at ballads; however, I like some of her new
attempts in this album like zao ge ren and the qing kuai song feng di
shou. Bu gan dang is another ballad rock song like yan wei die, makes
me feel less "stressed" after listening.
However, the most touching songs are of course her ballads which never
dies! Below are my fav recommended ballad songs in d album:-
Recommended:- qing ge, shu yu, yong li bao zhe, ai qing zhi shuo yi
wei ai qing, tian deng, bie zai wei ta liu lei, er ge
Final result:- 8.2/10 (Refer to U mag, about the same grading as mine)
I agree nowadays new albums v nice are mostly females like Joanna,
Cheer and Fish. I am glad this yr more and more female singers are
releasing albums. Finally the male singers get to "stand one side". Is
always the male singers are more "popular". This yr, is female time!
Jiayou!
Also there is a china singer Jane teo (zhang liang yin) who release
new album recently also not bad... the one (chao nu) who duet with Lee
Hom's ling yi ge tian tang. her new R & B album is pretty
impressive... can check it out!
to moses:
其实最大的问题出在于，当你一个情歌天后到了第十张专辑，出了一张叫
“静茹&情歌”的专辑时，理应我们应该听到超越前作的优秀情歌，才能符
合专辑所标榜的。可是当词曲都无法达到预计的时候，那种失望真的会扣
下很多分数。
其实静茹还是唱的很好，只是歌曲真的收得不如以往。分数很多时候是和
自己比，5分，就仿佛是最好的梁静茹的一半。
to peter:
是啊，我同意静茹需要突破。那些比较有突破的歌曲，我都有给予肯定。
老黄瓜 Says ：
我不觉得我是 Nasty 。
我们这里没有大爱精神，不喜欢的东西，没有必要假装喜欢。
这个世界很简单的。
给低分的时候，不赞同的都会跑出来，因为是低分。
可又不见的打下高分时，大家记得。
写好的，仿佛是应该。
写不好的，就叫刻薄。
这个世界哪里有那么多好东西。
我们不追求和别人一样，但也不代表我们刻意特立独行。
如果你问我们 Freshmusic 为什么可以看，那就是我们都忠于自己的想
法，自己的直觉/听觉，而不是别人的 Copy。
熟读老黄瓜乐评的，大概已经可以掌握到/猜到我喜欢听些什么，就好像
也不难猜测九层塔等人喜欢些什么。
You can don't buy that, but that doesn't mean we are bad.
我喜欢"别在为他流泪"!
我喜欢"别再为他流泪"!
对不起,笔误
maybe the focus is not on “静茹&情歌", but "别在为他流泪"? since this
album seems to move away from the usual emo and sad songs she usually
do... haha.
just an add-on, i guess most listeners would have preferred fish to
stick to her usual ballads instead, since that is her strongest area. ;D
to cucumber:
nice one. and that's the reason I've been reading Freshmusic since
2plus years ago.
everyone has different comments towards things. not having the same
sentiments as magazines or what doesnt mean anything, AT ALL.
it just mean that, cucumber has a different liking?
LOL.
and seriously, her ballads are all the same. =="
but shu yu is nice, ^5 cucumber!
lol, dont all ballads sound the same?
but i must say that the qu feng of her new album is not as mainstream
as before. maybe that's why it doesnt sound as nice as b4... summore
she queen of ballad... naturally will have high expectations of her
singing mainstream music.. haha.
我认为情歌绝大部分都是主流的，也包括所有收录在静茹这张专辑的。
我只分感动或者不感动我而已
這張專輯讓我放棄梁靜茹
我覺得比親親那張還不值得
最喜歡的還是絲路跟崇拜